Why Being Naturally Skinny Is Hard. And Why Some Asians Are Skinny

Being naturally skinny and thin isn’t always a blessing. It’s usually far from it. Just like those on the heavier side, a number of us skinny people often get grief and discriminated over the way we look.

For my whole life as an Australian of Chinese heritage, I’ve been skinny. At school in Melbourne (and later Malaysia and Singapore), I was always the thinnest among my classmates. Skinny bones, twiggy, stick, flat chested like a surfboard…I heard all those nicknames back then and felt like a walking freak show.

No matter how skinny or curvy we look, we're all beautiful in our own ways | Weekly Photo Challenge: Intricate.
No matter how skinny or curvy we look, we’re all beautiful in our own ways | Weekly Photo Challenge: Intricate.

Only once in Australia have I met someone as skinny as me. According to a national health survey conducted in 2012, just 1.7% of the Australian population is underweight.

Some people look at us who are skinny and think we’re unwell, think there’s something physically wrong with us even if we exercise and eat well. Having a non-skeletal-looking body is favoured in some Asian cultures – it’s symbolic of affording to eat well and living a fairly well-off life. At Chinese family gatherings, it’s not uncommon for someone (usually from the older generation) to loudly gush how “fat and big” the long-time-no-see cousin/aunt/brother/blood relation looks after packing on a few kilos.

There are some who think skinny isn’t a good look, that a skinny body is an undesirable façade. This isn’t much of a surprise since “skin and bones” is the common face of death. Growing up, my mum nagged me to gain weight and said if I didn’t, my face would become “ugly, sunken”, akin to the hollow cheeks of numerous waif-thin Caucasian women. In Asian cultures, round cheeks are prided upon, usually giving one a youthful look that is lusted after by many in this cultural group.

Being skinny, we might feel unloved in the realm of physical affection. Countless times when I hugged someone, they said, “Stop hugging so hard! Your arms hurt me!”. As the laws of physics state, for a given force, if the surface area is smaller, the pressure is greater. Maybe spindly arms and legs do inflict much pain on others.

There are some who think skinny people are lucky to eat what they want and stay in the pink of health. For some of us on the thin side, this is true. For others, not so – a skinny person might have hyperthyroidism, Crohn’s disease or other health ailments affecting their figure.

Some of us of Asian heritage tend to be skinnier than Caucasians for arguable reasons. Serving sizes are smaller in Asia compared to Western countries, so Asians living in Asia are inclined to consume less calories and perhaps resulting in thinner figures. Moreover, it’s customary to have at least a dish of veggies with many an Asian meal.

Sometimes when we're skinny, it's hard to feel beautiful as we feel like we don't belong.

Many in Asia still make a living doing manual labour, which takes a toll on bodies. For instance, in China millions of farmers stoop under the sun planting rice. Genetics and high metabolism are also debatably reasons why some Asians tend to be of skinny stature.

These days desired beauty is unfortunately idealised stereotypes. It’s ironic how the world applauds certain skinny people and shames other skinny people. Don’t we always applaud athletic sprinters with dainty-looking muscles and nod understandably at those who are lithe and into exercising and dieting? Don’t we often express the least bit of surprise when we find out a skinny someone eats a lot but isn’t the physically active kind? Thinness is associated with the negative, especially eating disorders. In Australia, almost a quarter of young women develop anorexia nervosa and 5% of the population suffer from bulimia, and the fact these disorders can be overcome is often overlooked.

The hate on skinny (and curvy) is partly due to insecurity, jealously and our desire to fit in. We compare ourselves to others to learn from them and better ourselves. It’s no surprise we are tempted to emulate those we idolise, emulate their mannerisms and even body shape. “Look good, feel good”, as the saying goes and a phrase constantly featured in weight loss ads. Why not “feel good, look good” instead? Feel good with a bit of flab around the waist or feel good with ruler-like arms?

In a world so obsessed with body image, it’s easy to forget what “healthy” really is. Healthy is a lifestyle and different for each of us, depending on health conditions we may have – exercise, food, sleep, choices we make that affect how we feel physically and mentally. There are millions of things we can do if we have good health, a million things to be thankful for. As dancing violinist Lindsey Stirling who overcame anorexia and the dilemma of looking “perfect” said, “No matter what you look like, that isn’t where your happiness is sourced.”

When we love ourselves for who we are, skinny or curvy or in between, the world is at our feet.

Beauty knows no boundaries. Beauty, is intricate. There’s no such thing as a perfect body, and there’s also no such thing as an imperfect body. Our bodies change our entire lives: we pack on the pounds, pack it off or vice-versa as we age. Hormonal changes affect our weight too and so at times we can’t help the way we look.

In defense of naturally skinny people, being thin isn’t always a disease. Being thin, curvy or a shape in between isn’t something to be ashamed about. We’re all individuals with different looks, different talents.

Beauty. It’s about accepting who we are.

Have you struggled with being skinny? Do you know people who are thin?

176 responses to “Why Being Naturally Skinny Is Hard. And Why Some Asians Are Skinny”

  1. Matthew Curry Avatar

    You look lovely.

    It’s interesting that you said, “Having a non-skeletal-looking body is favoured in some Asian cultures.” In Japan, sumo wrestlers are idolized, aren’t they? I always thought that was strange. Usually, being overweight is so frowned upon. Especially in America.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Sumo wrestlers in Japan. That is a very interesting strand of thought. I don’t think it’s a sport everyone wants to get involved in. To get to the body size of a sumo wrestler would mean following a strict diet and going to regular checkups. Still, it’s a sport many in Japan love.

      Being overweight is frowned upon too in Australia. But it’s sort of an accepted lifestyle here, to be overweight.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Matthew Curry Avatar

        I know what you mean. That’s how it is here, too.

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          Many Australians like eating fine food – they look forward to pay day and go, “I can eat again”. And binge on takeaways which are really pricey here.

          Liked by 1 person

          1. Matthew Curry Avatar
            1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

              Sad world we live in. One that is too obsessed with image.

              Liked by 1 person

  2. autumnashbough Avatar

    Not me! I’m the opposite. I have a tall, muscular frame to begin with, and staying thin was always the problem. (Being able to lift greater weights than most of the guys in the gym was NOT a problem. I’ll admit it, that was fun.) But calorie-counting can be such an exercise in deprivation, when you dance. A dancer has to fit into skintight catsuits or figure-hugging dresses for waltz. Each competitive dance outfit came with a mental tag that might as well have been on the hanger — if I weighed 125 lbs, I could wear the catsuit, 130 for the West Coast Swing outfit, etc. When you are dancing, like any performance art, your appearance makes up a large percentage of your score.

    Almost every ballerina I know struggled with an eating disorder, which is why the (relatively) normal frame of Misty Copeland is inspirational for dancers everywhere.

    I might envy your dainty frame, Mabel, but ulcers and worrying about being too skinny sound even more miserable than keeping one’s calorie count low. 😦

    And besides, having a slow metabolism (despite tons of exercise/muscle) is going to ensure that if there’s a famine, everyone else is going to starve first. And then I will eat them. 😉

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      I’ve always wondered what it’s like to lift weights just like the guys. For girls, it’s sort of a way to get the guys to look your way at the gym 😉 Now that you mention it, you’re right. Dancers do have lithe frames and I suppose that their skinny frames helps with executing a good number of dance moves. It’s interesting to hear you say the ballerinas you knew struggled with eating disorders. I’m guessing the disorders revolve eating less or not eating enough…and so I”m wondering where on earth do they get their energy to dance. Dancing is after all a strenuous activity.

      Don’t worry about me, Autumn. I’m all right now. Just need to avoid eating acidic foods like tomatoes and oranges. That has been helping me a lot in the last few years 🙂

      Oooh, you’re a bit of a cannibal there. I think you can win Survivor 😉

      Liked by 1 person

      1. autumnashbough Avatar

        I don’t know that I got more attention at the gym — I didn’t grunt like the big guys or anything! But it was fun to watch the guys try and surreptitiously decrease the weights after a “girl” had been lifting. I got a kick out of that. (But it was only for leg muscles or abs. Can’t compete with male upper body strength. Mostly.)

        Mabel, you would have the perfect traditional form for ballet — thin and lithe. Ballerinas have amazing strength and control, but, yeah, they survive on very little food to keep a thin frame. Strength of will, I think. And youth.

        Other types of dancers tend to be more muscular, but we still have to watch the overall appearance. Also, if you have a partner who lifts you for theater arts or any kind of showcase, you don’t want him sweating and grunting. Or getting hurt. When I went out to dinner with one partner, he would give me the side-eye if I reached for a second roll…

        I am glad to hear that you’ve found an eating lifestyle that works for you. It’s hard, though, when everyone feels free to, ahem, “weigh in” on your size and eating habits. And my Chinese-American guy’s family looves to do just that. “Oh, you too fat!” (This is, of course, followed up by a big helping of noodles and char siu bao!)

        Yeah, I like to think I am the end product of peasant evolution — big and strong fieldworker who can survive on very little food. 🙂

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          Sounds like you had no problem holding it up beside the guys on certain weights. Girls can do anything if we put our mind to it, and if we’re capable of course 😉

          Surviving on very little food – that sounds so sad for ballerinas. I suppose if it’s ballet that they love doing, then that’s the sacrifice they have to make. I don’t know how you did it…for me, after I’ve been walking for a few hours outside, I usually need food to keep me from going cranky.

          That is so true of Chinese families. They will comment you’ve put on weight and yet insist you take more food when your plate is full of food. Also, you will never really find small portions of food when dining out with many Chinese…cooking too much is always better than cooking too little 🙂

          Liked by 1 person

  3. twentyroses Avatar
    twentyroses

    I am a skinny asian too. My friends made fun of me for having no boobs and people always ask me to eat more. They don’t get it because I’m eating a lot already. I came to love my body though, it’s doesn’t matter that I’m just skin and bones because it’s just how I am.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      So happy to hear that you love your body for what it is. As a skinny person, at times I do eat a lot too – I can eat a whole dish I ordered and then help my friends finish theirs on some days.

      “it’s just how I am” I wish more of us can think of beauty this way. Well sad.

      Like

  4. charuzu Avatar

    My daughter (24 yo) is on the skinny side and quite tall. She told me she was shopping for clothes and the sales assistant asked if she had anorexia. My daughter thought this was quite insulting. Just because some young Australian girls are on the chubby side doesn’t mean thinner girls have medical problems.

    Miss Mabel – I am pleased to read that you are comfortable and happy with your body and who you are. I love the new image (drawing) on your web site. Who is the artist?

    Charles

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      That is rather rude of the sales assistant to ask your daughter if she had an eating disorder. Very sorry to hear that. Perhaps the sales assistant was trying to be friendly in some way. Still, that was a personal question.

      I think for many of us, being comfortable with our bodies and who we are takes time. We get used to our bodies physically changing over time.

      Thank you, Charles. A talented illustrator called Anna, also known as Pinodesk, illustrated my header after we went through the concept together. I put a link to her on my blog’s sidebar.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Yingiex Avatar
    Yingiex

    Thank you for this post. I applaud you to bring up this oh-so sensitive subject.
    Thank you from the bottom of the heart of a skinny girl.
    Just because you’re skinny doesn’t say how healthy or how unhealthy you are. You can’t base everything of off looks. But unfortunately people forget that too often.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      You are right, Yingiex. Being skinny or curvy, and weight in general is a very sensitive subject. It’s probably because many, many of us aren’t happy the way we are, and maybe because it’s a sensitive subject, we don’t talk about it enough.

      Thank you for stopping by and reading. I really appreciate it.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yingiex Avatar
        Yingiex

        True that! However often because we feel bad about ourselves, instead of admitting we feel bad about our body etc, we instead push it away, and we lash out by dragging people down with us. I honestly believe that people who are truly happy don’t gossip and talk bad about each other, because they don’t feel the thrill of pushing people down. Because they are already truly happy.
        I think we need to start with ‘fessing up and we being honest with ourselves and each other, so there’s no need for this bully talk. And we really need to try to accept ourselves and others.
        With love,

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          “we lash out by dragging people down with us.” It really is a bit of a sad world we live in. Bullying will get us no where. Skinny or curvy or in between, we are all people with problems and dreams, and the least we can do is encourage one another.

          Liked by 1 person

          1. Yingiex Avatar
            Yingiex

            It is a sad world, however change starts with us. We are examples for everyone. For the neighbors, your friend, that little guy over the street and the upcoming generation, our children.
            Let’s do this! Just because it is sad, doesn’t mean it cannot become happy. Right?

            Like

            1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

              “We are examples for everyone” You are so right. Once we all start accepting ourselves for who we are, the world will be a better place!

              Liked by 1 person

  6. balroop2013 Avatar

    Hi Mabel,

    ‘Beauty lies in the eye of the beholder’ and I also feel real beauty lies within…in our heart and soul, in our thoughts and actions. Having said that I must also point out that most of the models and actors who try to stick to size zero are said to have a perfect body! Have you ever seen a fat mannequin, wearing the latest trends? I also feel it is a blessing to be thin because you don’t have to think twice before gobbling your favorite sweets and chocolates!

    I have always been very weight conscious, probably because I seem to have such a gene that if I eat a hearty meal for a week, I put on extra pound within days! As a teenager I too was quite thin, with extra long and thin limbs but with the passage of time, fat slowly kept accumulating till I realised it was time to watch it and I did so, most religiously. So I managed to maintain it by eating healthy food and restricting the chocolates and ice-creams.

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this topic, they are quite thought-provoking and also good for those on the other side of the fence!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      It’s sad that the fashion industry likes to employ models with skinnier figures all the time. Skinny sells, that seems to be the general consensus. Society still has some way to go to recognise that every shape is beautiful.

      “real beauty lies within…in our heart and soul” Well said. Actions always speak the loudest words. Good to know that you know how your body works and how it reacts to certain foods. Always important to know since health is a gift, health is fragile.

      Thank you for always sharing insightful perspectives. Much appreciated, Balroop.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Sue Slaght Avatar

    Mabel I have spent much of my life being told I was too thin, I should eat more, etc, etc. I have always found it fascinating that it would be deemed acceptable to tell a person they were too skinny but if someone said to another they were too fat it would be considered rude. If you are happy and healthy that is all that matters. Don’t let them get you down.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      So true. Saying someone is fat is never a compliment, and likewise saying someone is skinny. Sometimes our body shape has got something to do with our bones too – the bigger our bones, the more weightier we might seem.

      I am very happy too see a healthy, happy and always smiling Sue in your photos. Confidence right there.

      Liked by 1 person

  8. Rebecca Rossi Avatar
    Rebecca Rossi

    Hi Mabel! I now see what you mean when you said you related to my previous post 🙂
    I really enjoyed your post – it was relatable and expressed really well. I too have always been petite and my stomach is small so I get full incredibly quickly! There have been times where I’ve refused meals simply because I was too full and my mother and sister would claim I may have an eating disorder. It can be incredibly frustrating not wanting a second helping or refusing dessert and having your family give you worried looks. I have never once had an eating disorder. I am simply full! 🙂 It sounds like you can really relate which is nice. I’m sure you are very huggable 🙂 they say good things come in small packages and I’ve always believed that to be true! No matter if you are skinny or on the heavier side, we are all beautiful and just wanted to be loved and accepted for who we are. There are so many articles out there about bigger people that feel like are being judged but the same does go for skinny people too so I’m glad you have brought it to attention xxx

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Small stomach. That is something that completely eclipsed my mind while writing this. Thank you for bringing this up. Maybe some of us who are short and small in stature have smaller stomachs and so are compelled to eat less like you.

      Very sorry to hear others have thought you have an eating disorder because of this. There needs to be more education about this, and there is a common conception that those who are curvier do not suffer from it, which isn’t true.

      Well, if you hug me one day, then you can judge whether I hurt others or not 😉 It could even be my superpower! In all serious, you are right. We are all beautiful and “to be loved and accepted for who we are”. Hate doesn’t get us anywhere, so let’s fight with love ❤

      Like

      1. Rebecca Rossi Avatar
        Rebecca Rossi

        Definitely! Smaller stomachs mean less room for food 🙂 of course if I wanted to put on weight I could but I would probably get quite sick first and then my stomach would stretch and go larger over time. I’m happy eating just the right amount of food that suits me 🙂 as I’m sure you are too! Haha there is much power in a hug and love is our greatest weapon 🙂 xx

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          I like how you break down overeating. It’s such an uncomfortable experience. Usually counting and increasing our calorie intake is the way to gain weight, but we should always consult with a doctor first. I’m happy that you are happy with yourself. Love ourselves for who we are ❤

          Like

  9. CrazyChineseFamily Avatar

    I never had the problem to be skinny, except in my early childhood. For many years I had the exact opposite, as I love food I have no problem at all to gain up to 12kg within few weeks!
    During my active sport days I had been on a eating plan and that eating behavior continued while my training sessions per week declined more and more till I quit swimming, hence the weight problem in the beginning. Now I am more balanced but lately I got again rather much weight due to the stresss I am experiencing and I hope the solution me and my wife came up will help with both my mental and my physical health.
    From the people I met so far I know more “Caucasians” who are really skinny the way they are without wanting to and less Asians but then again I met much less Asians in my life to begin with. For example my parents in law are really really skinny yet they eat nearly double what I eat. The amount my mother in law is eating here is just incredible as I would have to throw up half way through yet she is not gaining any weight, she even eats in the middle of the night!
    It is always strange what is perceived as beauty these days, I lost long ago track of it 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      I supposed when you were swimming you had to maintain muscle, or maintain a heavier weight and that was with the help of trainers at the school. A strict exercising and eating regime for the sport, that is what I mean…like you’re selling your health away for a greater cause…

      I hope you eat healthy and feel less stressed soon. Health is wealth. As for MIL, she sounds like a crazy eating machine. I need to see her in action to believe it.

      Like

  10. Ray Avatar

    Be comfortable in your own skin, if you can…

    People really shouldn’t say things like that to you. People are awful. Why would anyone think it okay to comment on appearances like that, especially on certain sensitive body parts??

    Really nobody has the right look. Everyone is wrong from some point of view. Ideally, it would be better to be true to yourself and not worry about others’ perceptions. Easier said than done. Accept who you are.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      “Everyone is wrong from some point of view”. Spot on. We are all imperfectly perfect, or perfectly imperfect. Very inspiring words from you. Maybe you should write an inspiration-themed book.

      I suppose some of us pick and tease how we look because they find it humorous. Or strange and odd. To them, they might feel like they are pointing out an observation not knowing that it can come across as insulting.

      Like

      1. Ray Avatar

        Inspiration? I dunno. But glad you think spot on

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          Yes. I thought your words were inspiring. Sometimes the most meaningful words manifest when we’re rambling away.

          Liked by 1 person

  11. Lani Avatar

    I love your new header and your new blog look! I’ve been waiting for this un-veiling 😛 Yeah, skinny. It’s all relative, but I suppose in your case, you are petite. At this point, as long as your healthy that is all that matters. I’m grateful for a body that moves and allows me to do the things I love and experience this great life. Hugs ^^

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      True. Petite people – and those with small bones – give the illusion that they are skinny quite a lot of the time. You certainly know how to cherish yourself, Lani. Good health, more smiles, another day, another chapter. Thank you, I love my new header. Finally got the way I want my blog to look after so, so, so long!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Lani Avatar

        Did you create your own header? I forgot to ask.

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          I created how I wanted the header to look. The girl, camera, monkey, globe. So you can say I designed it. I asked a very talented illustrator called Anna (or Pinodesk) to do the illustration with the help of photos, much credit to her. So there’s your answer.

          Liked by 1 person

  12. Dalo 2013 Avatar

    Very well written and thought-out post Mabel ~ it was great to get your perspective. For me, being a guy I always hated being thin (lithe and wiry how my coaches always explained it), and it was all eggs and protein shakes growing up 🙂 So for guys, everyone want to be big and quite different from a woman’s perspective.

    I think I was always aware of the opposite for women, where women strived to be thin, but a healthy thin. I think between the ages of 13 to 30 that was just the way things were. Perhaps they still are, but it seems now that the more shapely/curvy women are back in style…and there is less attention being put on skinny and/or full figured women. All is good, which is pretty great as it seems that society has made a conscious decision that all shapes are intriguing and sexy in their own way…although I do not know if it really the case as I have become pretty desensitized to societal trends these days 🙂 But it sure would be cool if it is where societal views are heading. Great post Mabel ~ and love your new header, you look awesome 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Very interesting to hear a guy’s perspective and your thoughts on this. I remember a few posts back you mentioned sport was a considerable part of your world growing up, hence that’s why now you’re saying you hated being thin back then as it meant less muscle and strength. Most of my guy friends in Australia my age would rather be a bit bulky with muscle than look, well, as you said, wiry (that is such an American word…we don’t hear it much Down Under).

      I suppose for many women, they want to be thin because that is equated to femininity and that’s the way they want to look, feminine. Hard to say if society really is heading in the direction of accepting all figures. Don’t know about that. At times we see and hear skinny/full-figured women speaking up, but to me that seems fleeting. But a step in the right direction nonetheless.

      Glad you like the new header. The girl with the bony arms really looks like me 🙂 Pinodesk the artist did a great job 🙂

      Like

      1. Dalo 2013 Avatar

        I think you are right, it is hard to say if society really is heading in the direction of accepting all figures ~ I think I am being too optimistic 🙂

        The new header really rocks, it is very, very cool and agree that the artist did a great job ~ wishing you a great day and coming weekend Mabel 🙂

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          Optimism is always good. Society still sees men with sizable figures as humans who are physically strong, and are able to pull off commanding without being domineering. On the other hand, society doesn’t usually associate strength with curvier women but usually perhaps have a bit of an attitude if they are confident with who they are. Strange, isn’t it.

          “new header really rocks” Very cool language there. Very, very cool and in 🙂

          Like

          1. Dalo 2013 Avatar

            Yes, I too think optimism is good ~ and to show my age “new header really rocks” is from my 80’s school days venacular 🙂

            Like

            1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

              Always thought you were much older than me, but you always sound young at heart 🙂

              Like

  13. maamej Avatar
    maamej

    I like the new look blog with the painting up top – very nice.

    I think being skinny was more common when I was a child because people didn’t eat so much in Australia as they do now, but I was still very skinny even for those times. I got teased for it – I was called ‘licorice legs’ because people thought my legs in tights looks like licorice strips. I can laugh about it now but it hurt a lot at the time. I guess it’s true that people always get teased for their appearance and we need to support children’s resilience so that they aren’t bothered by it. Good on you for championing the skinnies!

    By coincidence a friend gave me some photos of myself when I was in my late 20s and I was still very skinny then. Now I have a little bit of middle-aged spread, but it feels like not my body any more, so I exercise to keep it at bay and regain what I think of as my normal skinny body. I like the flexibility and agility that comes with being thin.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      So sorry to hear you got bullied for the way you looked back in the day, Maamej. But glad you can laugh about it now and feel comfortable with who you are.

      Interesting to hear you bring up that we didn’t eat that much a while ago and skinny was more prevalent then. I reckon that applies to other countries as well. Eating out and takeaway has become so popular over the last few years. So has dieting and fad detoxing (like tea detox, juice detox), though.

      Like

      1. maamej Avatar
        maamej

        Yes, the spread of fast food illness and eating disorders is awful. Our relationship with our food can be pretty twisted 😦

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          It doesn’t help that most of the nation’s most popular dishes aren’t what you call healthy foods (meat pie, chicken parma etc.). They do play a part in contributing to obesity and hence our obsession with body image.

          Liked by 1 person

  14. CL (RealGunners) Avatar

    People who discriminate against skinny people are people who are jealous, that’s all!! 😀

    Okay, on a more serious note, the fact that your mom nags on you to gain weight rather than being genuinely worried of other possible reasons for you being skinny, I suspect you simply don’t eat enough, although you think you do. Of course I am just speculating, since I have never seen you eat before. It is a bit similar to my little sister, she eats the equivalent amount of what a 6-year-old eats and she insists that she is eating a lot and accuses us of being in conspiracy to turn her into a giant fatty. :/

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      You have every right to be suspicious that I don’t eat enough. I wonder that too. It depends. When I’m working then I’ll have money to buy full meals to eat or cook (which has been the case for the last couple of years). If I’m tight on finances, I skimp and have half a lunch and a full dinner. How hungry I feel and how much I eat at each meal also depends on what I ate before – for instance if I had a creamy pasty for lunch then I usually want a small dinner. How much I eat also depends on whether if it’s that time of the month.

      Please don’t bully your little sister and her food. As long as she is healthy, that is all that matters 😀

      Like

  15. Mara Eastern Avatar

    Thank you for this lovely and encouraging article. Very thoughtful and insightful, and well written as usual. I assume most people are uncomfortable with their body, whatever their body type, and nasty people will always find a reason for shaming others. Unfortunately.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Thank you, Mara. You are very kind for reading this long post and didn’t fall asleep! Agree with you. When people are insecure or full of themselves, they might not say the nicest things. The body is a very sensitive topic, an easy way to bring someone down in terms of words.

      Liked by 1 person

  16. lolaWi Avatar

    what is important for me personally is happiness. as long as i’m happy being thin or heavy, the rest don’t matter. i was skinny for a long time and then got a little heavier. of course i heard all sorts of comments but none affected me. i am happy the way i am and i’ll stay that way. great topic as always, Mabel. 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      What a great attitude you have there, Lola. Be happy, be carefree, and everything will fall into place. I suppose a lot of us are concerned about being skinny or curvy because first impressions count. Then again, first impressions rarely tell the true story about us. Keep being happy, keep being yourself 🙂

      Like

  17. Beth Avatar

    I was also really skinny at school and university. It wasn’t until about 10 years ago that I started to gain any weight. I used to eat well and take two sandwiches to school every day! People used to comment on that and my weight all the time. I was called ‘twig’, ‘stick’ etc. I think it’s incredibly unfair how so many people like us are bullied for being skinny. It’s not something that can be controlled. You can’t just ‘eat’ to gain weight but more to the point it is unhealthy to do so!
    Growing up I wanted curves so that boys would find me attractive but I didn’t want to eat junk for the sake of it and I rarely felt compelled to drink sugary drinks. I didn’t have an eating disorder. I just lead an active lifestyle. I used to swim a lot and worked in my parents restaurant at weekends and school holidays (they say the average waitress walks three miles per night). At the same time my peers were all out drinking, smoking or sat around watching tv. Maybe if I wasn’t so active, I may have gained a bit more weight but I have a strong feeling that I would have still been small because of my oriental roots. I’m 5 ft 4 and my mum is 5 ft.
    Anyway, Ive rambled on for longer than I should’ve but I just want to say before I go that I really identified with your post and thank you for sharing. I also think you look perfect to me. Bx

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      So sorry to hear that you were bullied when you were younger for being skinny. But good on you for not listening to them and eating healthy. Each of us have different bodies that respond differently to the foods that we eat and the choices in our lifestyles. I suppose eating home cooked food or packing lunch does go some way to staying a relatively smaller shape than others – we tend to put more thought into cooking when we’re the ones making our own meals.

      “You can’t just ‘eat’ to gain weight but more to the point it is unhealthy to do so!” Very emphatically said, and I agree with you on this. Not only is it unhealthy, but stuffing your face with food does make you sick to the stomach at times. I’ve tried it to gain weight, and will never do it again.

      Love how you are so positive, Beth. You look beautiful just the way you are, and I can see that your kids love you just for you 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  18. Holistic Wayfarer Avatar

    I chuckled at the title – the things you come up with! But it’s a serious and important post, M. I could relate in many ways. My parents’ final words on their death bed will be the injunction that I put on weight. I most certainly will, with the load of guilt on my back. =) (My wrists are as thin as yours.) It’s hard esp for females, with societal standards for physical beauty. I couldn’t add to your wisdom, that health is what is important – and is the essence of beauty. What suddenly comes to mind is Marilyn Monroe. She was sick – mentally and physically. The chemical addiction to Px ruined her liver and enslaved her. But no one looked more beautiful, right? The magic word is looked. It’s unfortunate that this word is what matters to so many but hey, you LOOK like you’ll be enjoying a BeaUtiful, more satisfying, wholesome life than Monroe was able to. It’s your life. Be all in it.

    “Don’t care since they don’t affect how I see, walk, talk and my ability to write stories as a writer.”
    You bet.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Beauty, and body image, is such a sensitive subject, and I believe one that many of us fear discussing, even in a respectful setting. Why? Probably because we’re insecure. Probably because we don’t like being stereotyped, and deep down we have pride for the way we look and don’t want that taken away from us.

      Marilyn Monroe is amazing, and a fitting example. But so sad. One can be so beautiful inside and outside but can’t be happy.

      BeaUtiful. You are so smart, D. What a great play on words. Your words are always so beautiful, and I love your recent gravatar change – radiant and ravishing.

      Like

      1. Holistic Wayfarer Avatar

        You have had nothing but beautiful words for me, Mabel. I appreciate you bunches. (I’m confiding something here, not fishing for objection, so humor me: all I can think, at the sight of the new gravatar, is that I look old. LOL. Case in point: we are just not satisfied, are we?) Rhetorical question bc you answered it already. Have a great wknd.

        Xxx
        D.

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          Old in your gravatar? That was the last thing I would use to describe it. Classy also came to my mind when I first saw it, and those shades frame your face well. I also thought your other gravatar was very pretty – in that one you looked like you were drifting like no care in the world, as delicate as gossamer. And that is a compliment ❤ We are never satisfied perhaps because we want to improve ourselves…it's in our nature.

          You have a god one too.

          Like

          1. Holistic Wayfarer Avatar

            “as delicate as gossamer.” lolololol…I REALLY wish you hadn’t run with this but again, thank you, M. LOL. You’re right – we are never satisfied. How sad that I will stick to my judgmt and still be bothered by it. =) Enough! Go pour buckets of encouragement over other bloggers, you.

            Xxxx
            D.

            Like

            1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

              You are very humble, D. Much love to you.

              Like

  19. Hoarder Comes Clean Avatar

    How we see our bodies swings back and forth, doesn’t it? The 1600’s had Rubens, the 1960’s had “Twiggy”, and it went back and forth in between, and ever since. And now it occurs to me that those changes mostly refer to women’s bodies — men’s ideals stay much the same. Once I heard a young woman explaining her job in advertising: using photoshop, she made the models thinner and elongated their legs.
    I love your thin and curvy trees. Nice visual metaphor.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Love how you bring a historical twist to this topic, and the fact that we perceive weight differently speaking of different genders. The burlier and bigger size a man is, the more likely we think of him as having more physical strength. Rarely do we associate this trait with women, women are heavier unless they have visibly taut muscles.

      Thanks, Sandy. I really wasn’t feeling this set of photos, but glad you liked them and the story behind them.

      Like

  20. lisadorenfest Avatar

    I was ‘too’ skinny most of my life and really wanted to be curvy. I guess that we all want what we can’t have. Recently, I have developed some curves and now miss the skinny little twig that I was . But I am able to laugh at myself these days and love myself for who I am. My secret is to look at myself in the mirror from the perspective of me 10 years in the future looking back. I find that, in hindsight, I always look better than I thought I did at the time :-).

    You are absolutely adorable. You just need to own your adorableness 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      So happy to hear that you are comfortable with yourself. That is amazing. Thank you for sharing your secret – our future, older selves are really the wise ones having gone through a million more experiences 😉

      Beauty is all around us. Beauty is always within us. Nothing can take that away from us unless we say that we’re not beautiful…we all really are. You are very adorable too since you own your body just the way it is 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  21. Jess Avatar
    Jess

    I’m assuming I’m the person you mentioned there 🙂 We have discussed this in person and this is the same struggle I’ve experienced for very long.

    I have been asked many times if I’m anorexic, as has my mother when she has been around me. I have had people wrap their fingers around my wrist and remark how small it is. I’ve had school teachers asking if I’ve had my breakfast. I’ve had people tease me for my chicken legs, bully me for wearing tight clothes because I look ‘disgusting’ and the list goes on.

    During this time, people did not know I had Coeliac Disease and so could not control my weight due to an autoimmune disease. I saw multiple doctors like you Mabel, that told me to eat more, and I too resulted in throwing up after meal as the sheer volume of food made me I’ll and my body couldn’t cope.

    This post means a lot to me to read I’m not alone. It took me a long time to accept my body as it is and I truly hope this post will help others, the minority, that deal with this stigma and judgement daily.

    Thank you

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      You are right. I was referring to you at the start of the post 🙂 Thank you for inspiring this post. I’ve been wanting to write it for two years now. Finally it’s done and dusted, weight off my shoulders.

      I am very sorry to hear that the ones closest to you questioned you constantly about the way you looked. The hate we receive does get overwhelming. If not, those around us seem to find perverse fascination with skinny bodies…and now thinking of it, I don’t know which is worse. Just last week, a colleague of mine said to me, “Your arm is so small” in front of everyone in the office. Everyone is different.

      I hope you have Coelic Disease under control. It sounds like you do, good on you 🙂 It’s certainly not easy being a skinny person. Some of us have to put up with being underweight for medical reasons, which leads to having less strength which isn’t helpful…like when it comes to pushing open heavy doors :/

      Thank you for supporting. You don’t know how much it means to me, and how much I appreciate it ❤

      Like

  22. maureenc Avatar

    As a youngster I was “too skinny”. As I’ve aged and physically slowed down the weight has piled on, even though my appetite is much smaller than it used to be . Unfortunately, most people don’t put their brains into gear before they start commenting on our physique and can be quite hurtful and are blissfully unaware (or uncaring) of the injury they cause.
    Yesterday, on another blog I follow I read these words of wisdom:

    You are enough.

    You are a beautiful human being.
    You have a personality, a humanity, a way of being
    that is yours and no one else’s,
    and that makes you precious and loved and loveable.

    You are enough.

    You are something of unique and inestimable value.
    Within your own heart there is a sparkling,
    twinkling light of worth, dignity, beauty, and love.

    You are enough.

    You do not need to become someone else.
    You do not need to imitate this person or that one,
    no matter how famous, talented or privileged
    they may happen to be.
    You do not need this person’s intelligence or
    that person’s talent or another person’s wealth.
    And you do not need any other person to become like you.

    There is only one thing that you need.

    You need yourself.
    You need to become yourself.
    You need to imitate yourself.
    You need to love yourself.

    You are enough.

    And before I sign off I must add how much I like the artwork in your new header.
    Hugs and admiration for you once again sharing your thoughts with us.
    Maureen

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Thank you very much, Maureen. It never ceases to surprise me how people are so quick to judge when they see how small or big we are. Maybe it’s a matter of education. Maybe we need more programs in schools on positive body image and the factors that affect the way we look.

      That poem is amazing. “You are enough”. Such profound words. May I ask for the blog where you found this poem? I would love to pay them a visit.

      Thank you for liking my new header. A talented illustrator called Anna (or Pinodesk) helped me to put it together. She is amazing.

      Like

  23. phb2003 Avatar

    Mabel – this is such an interesting read – I like how you noted “genetics and metabolism” are often the reason and just cannot compare. I think more elementary and middle school students need to read stuff like this post.
    … anyhow, my two sons are very strong athletes – played sports since toddlers – and usually year round – but they are also on the skinny side – muscular and strong – but skinny -and we have had many conversations about their different gifts and strengths that come with their particular physique – but sometimes it has just been tough. For example, when my older son played lacrosse – the coach refused to let him play defense – we even bought the expensive long pole defensive stick – and then he was told that because he ran so well, they could not just have him hanging back on D – and the one coach said they need the bigger thuds there – something like that – trying to be cool – but it was wrong – my son was robbed of playing the spot he wanted to play – and he actually was good at D because he was good at scanning and knew when to hold back or run up – but it was so irritating that he was penalized indirectly for his size.
    But you are so right with so many angles here – how on one hand we complement or idolize a certain body trait – and celebrating diversity starts with appreciating that we have different body shapes/sizes for many reasons.
    And for males, I think that too often a larger body size is perceived as more masculine (and I am just talking about body frame and arms and all that) – anyhow, you wrote so potently about a very layered topic. 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      So sorry to hear that your son wasn’t given much opportunity to play defense for lacrosse – all based on his fairly thinner than others stature. I suppose some coaches think that they bigger the body, the more one can block the goal. Well, without skill I won’t be surprised if the ball/sporting thing you hit around depending on the game will whizz past you more than once…

      Often when we think of skinny or curvy, we automatically think about weight. True, most of the time the skinnier we are, the less we are. But sometimes that’s not true – some of us might have heavy bones. Bone structure also often goes some way towards whether we look skinny or not – small bones tend to give the impression that we’re small in size.

      Glad you brought up gender. As I mentioned to Sandy earlier, “The burlier and bigger size a man is, the more likely we think of him as having more physical strength. Rarely do we associate this trait with women, women are heavier unless they have visibly taut muscles.”.

      Thank you for your very nice words, Y. Actually, I felt like I could have ended the piece differently. But that’s my writer’s hat talking there, I will stop chatting and not go there 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. phb2003 Avatar

        well I hope to come back and read all of the comments here – there is a unique energy to your blog posts, which I think is a mix of things. Like you are willing to “go there” on topics, you open up. you have tons of life seasoning (which I have said before) and then you write so darn well. Okay = enough kudos – but for some reason I did not notice this when I visited your blog last year (I dropped by here and there) but maybe I was just trucking through with visits and did not take the time to taste the cuisine (okay that is cheesy)

        anyhow, Like that quote with the gender thing – and with my son and the lax coach that year – that was real the only coach we have ever had that did that – but I also see why – she had to balance her team – but she also was a below average coach (nothing personal).

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          Maybe your son can back into sports once again at some point. Who knows what he can do on the field now without a coach in his face. Our bodies also change over time too…the older I’ve gotten, I’ve realised I’ve packed on a bit of weight here and there (though am still very skinny) and feel stronger because of it.

          Ah, Y, you really are too kind. “taste the cuisine…” Now you’ve got me chuckling 😀 Maybe it’s not you, maybe it’s me – I feel more confident as a writer than I did last year. I really can’t take all the credit for the energy here though (thank you, what a compliment)…a big chunk of that goes to you and all the rest who have chimed into the conversation. I’m just a skinny girl with a couple of perspectives, and I’m honoured to read others’ when they share 💕

          Like

          1. phb2003 Avatar

            well regarding the sports, that was many years ago and he only played lax for one more year after that – and I think he did lose interest because his heart was in the other position – which he played in practice and whatnot. But he also was more into soccer and check this out – going from three years of fall and spring lax – well when he went back into soccer he had a new force. You see – in lax they run with tons of gear on and hold a stick – and so there he was with shin guards and his first year back we were all floored by his performance. soccer was always his strongest sport – but that first year back after lax was fun. anyhow. he played 3 more years and now is in college and has put sports on the back burner. He had a small back injury his junior year – (and I actually was going to post about his sporting experience last spring but ran out of time) anyhow, it sucked because his small injury got worse because he did not rest it adequately – but he is pretty content with the way things worked out for him.
            anyhow M – I think you could probably write 5 books about the skinny topic -and still not run out of angles or side thoughts – it is a very layered topic….

            Like

            1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

              I am so sorry to hear about your son and his small back injury and it got worse. You never know, he could always get back to playing sport at some point, or maybe even a different sport. There’s always a sport for each kind of body and physique.

              You are right. Being skinny or curvy or any shape in general is such a layered topic. There’s also social aspects to it, a gender aspect to it all which I didn’t touch because my article was long enough already.

              Like

              1. phb2003 Avatar

                thanks so much M 🙂 ❤ – and his back is completely fine now – but it took an entire 6 months of rest – amazing how the body will heal when we rest it up.
                and I also agree that going into the gender part would have interfered with the flow of this particular post – which in my humble opinion was perfect. and again, not to flatter – but each section really flowed with your style and was aligned with that mix of what you have learned, what you think about, and your personal feelings – and any more would have taken form the taste of this "meal" – like getting served dessert too soon – or like getting a taco after eating italian cuisine – so leave the gender for another time… and I was just skimming an article (a cool one on confidence) and the author specifically said he was writing three columns to cover different areas – and so just affirming again that not touching the addition trails was more of your seasoning in a action.

                Like

                1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

                  Thank you for your very nice words, Y. You are so kind. Maybe one day I will revisit this topic again. Who knows 🙂

                  Liked by 1 person

                  1. phb2003 Avatar

                    🙂 – well I thought of your rich post again this last weekend – we went to see my niece perform and she has had the opposite experience all her life – she has been in gymnastics since she was able to walk – and then she comes from an Italian family where they eat lost of rich foods – and so she has always been curvy or big-boned – and actually so strong that she was stronger than her two brothers for many years. anyhow, I love how she is so confident with her frame now – even though for a couple of years I know she was working through “accepting” her genetics and life developing –

                    Liked by 1 person

  24. Jess Avatar
    Jess

    I wrote a long reply this morning on my phone and it didnt come up :/ But anyway, basically I wanted to say thanks for posting this for all the skinny people out there. We’ve spoken at length about this together in private but I was interested to read you’ve had many similar experiences with the medical feild that I have. Would have been earl last year, I was referred to a dietitian who told me to eat extra meals like you were told. I had the same issue, constant vomiting.

    I am Coeliac and so that is the blame to many of my issues with not being able to put on weight, but of course that never stops people judging you, calling you anorexic, asking when you ate last, measuring your wrists with their fingers, or telling you that wearing tight clothes is “unattractive” because you’re “skeletal”.

    I’m thankful you wrote this post, and I’m thankful I’m not alone 🙂 Thank you.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      I am so sorry your comment disappeared. It was in the Spam folder and I don’t get to check it until after work at night. But now it’s there! 🙂

      I am sure many other skinny problems exist than the ones I mentioned in this post. I didn’t touch on the social problematic aspects of being skinny – like how some bigger people think it’s cute to lift up skinny people off the ground and swing them around while giving them a hug. It’s dangerous, and one of the reasons I will never carry around a “Free Hugs” sign.

      You are beautiful, Jess. I am very glad to have met you (never saw it coming) and very glad to have you as a friend 🙂

      Like

      1. Jess Avatar
        Jess

        Ah yes I’ve had this too. When I was in grade six I remember some prep children ran up to me and picked me up. Yes, PREP children. Five year olds. It was terribly humiliating… 😐 Haha free hugs can be dangerous for us!

        Thanks again Mabel.
        Also I love the new header, saw it on my laptop at uni! I love the stuffed toy monkey there 😀

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          I hope you never get picked up like that again by kids. I’m sure others think it’s cute – like how they think skinny and small people are cute – but it really just isn’t because it’s dangerous 😐

          Thank you for checking out the new header. However I have to say that Mr Wobbles is the cuter monkey…and he holds a very special place in my heart 😉

          Like

  25. Febriyan Lukito Avatar

    I envy those who skinny because of my weight quite big. Hahaha. Well, after reading your post here, I am being grateful. Whatever body type we have, we have to be grateful.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      You don’t look big in your gravatar photo at all, Ryan. You are right. We need to be greatful for the body we have as it’s the only body we have. The only body to feel love and share love with others.

      Like

  26. Amy Avatar

    If they don’t like the color of skin, the accent,… will it make any, any difference to them if these Asian people are not skinny? I appreciate how you sharing your thoughts about “skinny”.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      I never thought about that. Wonder what people usually notice about others first: color of skin, body shape, hair style, clothes…I suppose it depends on the individual.

      But to answer your question…I will say no, it would not make a difference. Very, very interesting yet complicated question… :/

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Amy Avatar

        If they answer is a simple no, maybe, the question is not too complicated… 🙂

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          But…but…that really is such a complicated question you brought up 😀 Maybe body shape does stand secondary alongside race. I cannot wrap my head around this one *whooo

          Like

          1. Amy Avatar

            Probably something prompted me to say what I did that didn’t much make sense here… Sorry about that. 🙂
            I’m getting ready for my trip to Grand Canyon. 🙂

            Like

            1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

              No worries, Amy. The most random of thoughts are usually the most thought-provoking ones.

              Happy trip. I look forward to your Grand Canyon photos 😀

              Like

  27. Alexandra Avatar

    I have spent much of my life being told I need to lose weight…someone telling you how your body should look like is so wrong… as long as you are healthy, body shape does not matter… beauty is accepting who we are, can’t say this better 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      “someone telling you how your body should look like is so wrong” You’ve said it perfectly. There is no perfect shape in this world. Even our bones are formed differently. Beauty is not only in the eye of the beholder. It’s also how we view ourselves – it’s within each of us 🙂

      Like

  28. Constance - Foreign Sanctuary Avatar

    I think we all struggle with our body image [and physical appearance] from time to time. Plus, it seems like the ‘ideal’ body image differs from country to country and between cultures. However, I think it is important to accept the person we are and if we are comfortable with our own skin, then the opinions of others don’t matter.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Well said, Constance. There is no set standard for beauty as each culture prides beauty differently. The ones closest to us might object to us looking a certain way and that might hurt. As long as we have health, I suppose let things be and learn to love ourselves for who we are.

      Like

  29. Jean Avatar

    I never minded being thin when I was a teenager. I just minded being nearly flat chested until I realized it’s a blessing when one turns over 50… gravity is not pretty for more generously endowed women.

    I did have high metabolism like you Mabel in my 20’s and didn’t do any cycling. I just walked, took transit which can surprisingly help for daily health. I ate a lot more.

    Yes, cycling for transportation since I don’t drive, can help but…in the end, for many women, approaching perimenopause and menopause, women’s metabolism tend to slow down naturally. So being slim Asian descent now for me….comes from daily exercise, eating hardly any white rice, etc. that coincides with my slowing metabolism. It’s just life and part of aging. You might want to ask your mother how it was for her after she had her babies, then later ….as she ages.

    Sure I’ve had occasional people say I’m too skinny, etc. I don’t spend time defending nor thinking about it. I just occasionally tell people: this isn’t necessarily hereditary…I thank my mother for the foundation of her healthy Chinese cooking when I was growing up! It’s not to make other people feel bad but to remind them that Chinese home cooking is healthier than the Chinese restaurant meals (though they are delicious!). I need to give credit where it’s due. It’s hard to have children eat healthy most of the time and develop a broad palate.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Many people should take after you, Jean. You live a very healthy lifestyle in terms of diet and exercise, putting that first instead of the way our bodies look and not minding the naysayers. While being skinny or a certain shape can be put down to genetics, lifestyle plays a significant part too in how our body looks. Only occasionally do I eat out, perhaps about once or twice a week and I have to agree Chinese restaurant meals are no where near as healthy as home cooking, always dripping with oil. But for some of us the temptation of convenience that comes with eating out is so hard to pass up…

      As someone who has been skinny my whole life, I have had no problem with being flat chested – my chest has never gotten in the way of me running or bending and stretching here and there. No idea about other skinny people, though.

      Like

  30. Hsin-Yi Avatar

    Another reflective piece! Well done Mabel! I’m the opposite, I remember going to Chinese school and I’m the ‘big one’. Gosh I mean I wear a size 10! And remember some of my relatives when they see me comment on my weight – “oh you’ve gained a little weight!” or “oh you’ve lost some weight!” I think Asians have a different concept of weight because the average Asian has a thinner frame compared to other groups. In China I have to wear XXL or XXXL, and I would be considered on the fat side if I ever lived or worked in China.

    But I’m glad you are proud of who you are, we all come in different size, shape or form so we shouldn’t say which is better. And I love your quote “feel good, look good”. If you feel good and confident about yourself, you will look good. A confident person always brings a certain glow to other people.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      I’m sorry to hear your relatives pointing out your size. You are right about sizing and our perception of weight – certain parts of the world make smaller clothes because the people there are more diminutive in stature. I suppose it also depends on bone structure – some people haves smaller bones and might be considered thin, and those bigger bones on the heavier side.

      “we shouldn’t say which is better” Spot on. I would never see you as the big one, though. Probably the stronger one between me and you 😀

      Like

  31. themofman Avatar

    Many in body-conscious North America, perhaps especially women, envy skinny people. In Canada, many non-Asians find average to heavy-set Asians to be an extreme rarity. There’s even a longstanding presumption that Asian don’t like fattened physiques at all. This piece sheds a lot of light to refute that notion.

    By the way, I love your masthead graphic. Who’s the painter?

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      “Asian don’t like fattened physiques at all”. Sometimes yes, and sometimes no because it can be a cultural or personality thing. Sometimes I wish I could gain more weight and hence more muscle. Every body is different from a fitness perspective and we shouldn’t judge.

      Thanks, Mofman. Always appreciate it when you stop by. A talented illustrated called Anna (Pinodesk) illustrated the header for me after I chatted to her about the concept. There’s your answer.

      Like

  32. ShimonZ Avatar

    I have a very strong feeling that you know well, that one’s physical shape is just a part of whom we are, and that the personality and the character of a person has great influence in the matter of beauty. But even so, there are so many tastes… some like fat and some like thin. It was a great pleasure meeting you.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Your feeling is correct. Each person body’s shape is just a tiny part of who they are. Personality, demeanour, voice, heart and so on make up the rest of us – and each of these qualities change all the time, just like how our body shape changes throughout time. It was great meeting you too. Glad we’ve connected.

      Like

  33. Marta Avatar

    My boyfriend is very skinny, he weights 8 kilos less than me (and he is slightly taller). Luckily I don’t have body issues, if not I would be constantly mortified by it, haha.

    I think kids are very cruel and that is why many people are bullied when they are young (the bullies being other kids in school). If you are too fat, if you are too thin, if you have freckles, if you study too hard, if you have glasses, if you have brackets… there are so many things a cruel kid can pick on -_- I think the key should be education: teach kids that it is not ok to comment on other people’s physical appearance. The world might be a better place then 😀

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      You are certainly very proud of your body, Marta. Good on you. “kids are very cruel” Most certainly. Kids are naive and at the same time have wild imaginations…this is probably just me, but the rounder you are, the more likely kids are to see you as a villain or a villain character. I agree with you that education is key to get everyone to see every body shape is okay. Wish many P.E classes would be more than just running and playing sports.

      Like

  34. Irvine Chin Avatar

    make the best out of ourselves. love ourselves. skinny, average, chubby, fat, believed all have their advantages. And people out there favours different sizes! lol. however, there should be a mutual respect among all kinds 😉

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      So true. There really should be mutual respect among each other no matter our shape, as you say. Rarely does our shape affect what we love doing…self-confidence usually does. If we love ourselves for who we are, we’ll be confident and be able to tackle anything that we want to do 🙂

      Like

  35. lifeconfusions Avatar

    Oh man tell me about the struggle ! From what I gathered from the post I have the exact body type as you do. No matter what I just don’t gain weight. Since 8th grade my weight has been around 46 Kg’s average. The only reason I don’t appear as thin as other’s like me is because I’ve always been active in sports so it helped me to develop muscle mass or rather it shaped my muscles and body in a way my thin legs have at least nice bulk of calf muscles. at some point I had abs too. This just proves that I was never unhealthy and that this weight is not an abnormality. Some people are just made like that. Mos probably genetically.

    It’s a shame how we have become a society which judges everyone on there looks. We have made for ourselves such unattainable idols like celebrities who have ample amount of time and resources to make them look the way they are. We fat shame, we skinny shame…We shame everybody. This just results in low self esteem thus many mental health problems prevail too. It’s such a vicious cycle. You are so right, until and unless we are not comfortable in our own skin we will always be subjectifide , we will never see the true beauty for what it is.

    A great post Mabel, which hit too close to home for me. Thumbs up for such a thought provoking article ! 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      I sympathise heaps with you, Zee. I’ve been around the same weight since my late teens, or rather gained a bit more weight since then but still am tiny compared to majority of those around me. You with abs? That is amazing – you are both smart and athletic! 😀 Maybe the two of us are skinny because of genes.

      “We fat shame, we skinny shame…We shame everybody.” That is so, so, so true. Celebrities often watch their weight and look a certain way, supposing that there is some sort of perfect look in this world. While this is one way people express themselves through, there’s more to life than just looking a certain way.

      Thank you, Zee. You are very kind and thank you for supporting my writing as always. Good luck with your studies. You will do well. I know it 🙂

      Like

      1. lifeconfusions Avatar

        It’s a pleasure Mabel, it’s the least I can do for the amount of support and love you lend me ! ❤

        Oh by the way I absolutely loved your new header !! It is so cute and gives such a nice personal touch, such a perfect representation of your blog! Well done on that ! 🙂

        Like

  36. Meihsiu Hsiao Avatar

    Dear Mabel
    Asian concept, when we give birth to children, our elders want their children to be able to eat a little more, and then may look fat and strong, because it will give parents praise.
    However, we need to teach adults to maintain a good figure and appearance, a judge because a lot of people are starting from the first impression.
    I think as long as the health of their own self-confidence, inner thoughts will change the appearance gives the impression. 😉

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      You said it, Meihsiu. In my Chinese Malaysian family, my family have always bragged about their kids growing up and putting on weight – very similar to what you are saying. But yes, health is more important over body image, self-confidence is more important over our body shape. When we think positive, it will show on our face 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  37. Tina Schell Avatar

    Wow Mabel, you DO have a way of generating interest, don’t you?! I am naturally thin also, but can gain weight if I don’t watch what I eat and stay on my exercise program. There’s no such thing as a perfect body. people need to stop focusing on others and worry only about themselves.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      I…really don’t know anything about generating interest 😀 Just writing what’s on my mind like I’ve always been. Watching what we eat is a good thing because then we’re more conscious of what’s healthy and what’s not. At the end of the day, all body shapes are beautiful.

      Like

  38. Jasline @ Foodie Baker Avatar

    It’s very easy to say that we should not focus on others because the voices are everywhere, it’s hard to not be affected by these voices that came from family, relatives, friends, strangers etc. especially when we are not feeling confident of ourselves. Building up confidence is a long and hard path and I hope people out there will find it eventually, so that they will no longer be affected by those negative voices.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      It takes time to achieve confidence, you are so right. Sometimes the ones closest to us think they know what’s best of us. They may be right, or they may be not. All of us are individuals and hopefully through the hard times, we’ll be able to figure out what’s right for us. Thank you for reading 🙂

      Like

  39. Indah Susanti Avatar

    Nowadays being skinny is a popular choice. I am one of those people that you mentioned – who think skinny people are lucky to eat what they want and stay in the pink of health 😀 You are a lucky one, Mabel! I have to exercise regularly otherwise I will put on weight easily 🙂 I guess what matter is that we feel comfortable with our size..and stay healthy!

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Awww, my fellow skinny Asian! But in all seriousness, being skinny is hard sometimes and it really is due to a number of factors. I’m getting older…and I’ve realised if I eat certain bad foods too much, though they don’t make me put on weight, they make me feel sluggish. Better to eat healthy 😀

      Like

  40. dedy oktavianus pardede Avatar

    Honestly, my personal taste of woman is definitely NOT skinny, despite the possibility she may had a eading disorder and it definitely would be affect of my future kids, malnutriton during pregnancy also leading to mental, physic and intelectual health of the baby too…
    Definitely lovin someone with the secure inside, my ex-girlfriend is definitely fit but she always be bugging me about being overweight and it’s kinda insulting my big tall chubby tummy body, lol
    you’re all beutifull girl, no matter your size is, it’s the matter of health concern if you want to persue a fit body

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      That is a good point you bring up. Sometimes being skinny affects the reproductive system. Then again, if we don’t take care of our health, this part of us will not be too good either.

      No matter if you have a bit of weight around you, Dedy. As long as you’re healthy and live a healthy lifestyle, that’s what matters.

      Liked by 1 person

  41. Forestwoodfolkart Avatar

    Mabel, you often post about thought provoking and challenging subjects that need to be discussed more openly such as body image. Everyone is and individual and oh so very different so how can we expect everyone to have the same body shape? Metabolism rates often impact on this. I was flat chested and oh so tiny when younger, but hormones, childbirth and age change things, despite eating healthily. We should be able to appreciate each stage and eat healthily at each stage, no matter what that looks like. Encouraging skinny people to eat more is probably not the best idea for their digestive system, if they are healthy in themselves. Recently I saw an image of new Stockholm store mannequins on social media that was more akin to the “average” size of women. This helps women form better expectations around body image. Deep down that is what it is about, isn’t it? Acceptance of differences and of who everyone is, no matter their shape and size or what they look like. It is absolutely their own choice how they look and live. We are all on a spectrum of size and shape. But we are people first and foremost!

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      “Encouraging skinny people to eat more is probably not the best idea for their digestive system” I like how you say it. So often health is made up of so many things – how we feel physically and emotionally, our digestive system, kidneys, livers…basically every organ in our body. And you really wonder why there is so much focus on body image when it comes to discussing health. Ridiculous but maybe someday things will change.

      Very thoughtful of the Stockholm store to have mannequins of different sizes. Acceptance of body image starts with not laughing and poking fun at each other for how they look.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Forestwoodfolkart Avatar

        Absolutely agree with you Mabel. I think many of us can be too judgemental based on appearance only. This may stem from an evolutionary advantage, milleniums ago, ( we were drawn to healthy versus ill looking persons due to a survival mechanism), but is no longer relevant and in fact, detrimental to us in the modern world. On top of that the media and public attitudes are at fault for obscuring the real meaning of ‘beauty.’ For I find people who are kind and content, have a beauty that glows brighter, no matter what their size and shape.

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          The media certainly has a considerable part to play in what many of us deem a “perfect” body…all to get “eyeballs” I suppose. If we’re happy on the inside, it will certainly show through our eyes and rest of the face. After all, true happiness comes from within.

          Liked by 1 person

  42. Imelda Avatar

    I think most of us go through some body issues. I am no exception. I was(and still am) on the plump side and when I was a teen-ager I heard boys saying nasty things about me. Needless to say, I did not like my body and myself too much and I was full of insecurities. My most ardent dream was to be tall and well-proportioned that I would be able to scoff at the people (who happened to include relatives as well) making fun of me. When I was in my late 20’s, I tried to limit my food intake and would feel so guilty if I indulged a bit. Thank God, I have come to terms with my physical attributes – I guess it helped a lot that I found love even when I do not have a perfect bod. 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Sorry to hear that you were teased for your size. Those boys sounded like they needed a lesson in beauty and body image. But very glad to hear you’ve accepted the way you are, Imelda. Each of us has our unique shape.

      Speaking of being tall, I’ve always wondered what does the world look like quite a few centimeters up 😀

      Like

  43. Little Borneo Girl Avatar

    Hi Mabel, I had been away from WP for a while and came into yours knowing I would be missing something. What a lovely change. How did you get that painting? Looks so like you. I love it so much. 🙂 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Thank you Jess for stopping by. I really appreciate your kindness and warmth. After coming up with the header design, I got a talented watercolour illustrator called Anna (Pinodesk) to draw it for me. I love it so much too :’)

      Liked by 1 person

  44. joshi daniel Avatar

    the first picture is so colourful and beautiful 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Thank you, Joshi. More colourful photos in my next posts 🙂

      Like

  45. Sofia Avatar

    What a great post Mabel! It does open up a discussion on the fact that society seems to want us to be thin, and for many people that is hard, but for naturally very thin (bony) people it is not something they like either.
    As I’m half Asian, I’ve half had these problems, to say it somehow lol. When I was small I was very thin and my mum would have a hard time finding skirts that wouldnt fall off me, haha. As a teenager I had moments of being ok, and moments of being very thin. It had nothing to do with eating disorders, I eat a lot! It was more to do with moments when I had bronquitis for ages (was sick for ages) or in uni was made to live in a students residence, where we were not fed toooo well. My dad would give me a hard time thinking I was bulimic or something, so annoying! Now I’m lucky that I’m slim and curvy at the same time, while I can eat loads and whatever I want to without problems 🙂
    On the other hand, here in Spain recently there was a bit of a thing going on with the being skinny topic. The current queen of Spain (last year the King stepped down so his son is the King now and his wife the queen, sounds straighforward, right? But we just cant get used to the fact that this woman is now the queen.. quite weird). Anyhow, she is very very skinny. She used to be a journalist before she married the prince (now king) and was very beautiful then. Since then she has gone onto looking way too bony. Sooooo., the thing is that she recently appeared in a public act wearing a shoulderless strapless dress that showed off all her bones. She had also just cut her hair into a bob, so the world could clearly see each bone in her neck, back. It was not a pretty sight as it was very sickly – anorexic looking. So there is a discussion, that hey maybe she is sick. Or maybe she is anorexic. And in that case (anorexic) she should definitely not be showing off her extreme thinness to the world, being the very public figure she is.
    Anyway, gosh, I’ve written so much it could be a blog post 😉 xx

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      You said it so well in your first paragraph, Sofia. I just love it: “…society seems to want us to be thin, and for many people that is hard, but for naturally very thin (bony) people it is not something they like either.” Like you, I do want more discussion about positive body image…but I’ve always been reluctant to talk about it. Writing this post, it’s one of the rare times I’ll ever talk about my skinniness. Everyone is different, everyone has different reasons for the way they look and some of these matters are very private (especially when real health matters come into play…and we all know how health is touch and go sometimes).

      I sympathise with you about finding skirts that don’t fit as a kid. My mum always threw a hissy fit when skirts I tried on slid to the floor after zipping them up… 😀 I hope the queen of Spain is just naturally skinny and not sick in anyway. It’s probably her business and if she wants to keep it to herself, it’s her choice and we should respect that 🙂

      Like

  46. Packing my Suitcase Avatar

    Me and my 2 sisters used to be veeery skinny when we were younger… but you know, with the age coming up, we end up gaining some weight and now we need to watch out 😀 I wish I was still skinny like I was though 😦

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Veeery skinny when you are younger…okay, I believe you! Maybe cut down on eating burgers these days. I know what you mean. I’ve been getting older to and stomach is getting less flat and more round. Less burgers for me too 😀

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Packing my Suitcase Avatar

        hahahaahah ohh my you make me laugh!!
        You are right… less burgers for us!!! 😀

        Like

        1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

          Well, laughing is a form of exercise…stomach exercise. Laugh too much and your stomach will hurt and maybe shrink 😀

          Burgers, I want to eat a burger now 😀

          Like

  47. Packing my Suitcase Avatar

    BTW I LOOOOOOOOVE the new look! ❤

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      THANK YOUUUUU! You helped out with this header, you know 😉 Thank you for the introduction to Anna. She is so talented ❤

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Packing my Suitcase Avatar

        You are most welcome!!! I am very happy that you liked her… she is indeed very talented and plus a very nice person!! 😀

        Liked by 1 person

  48. Cecilia Avatar

    Everybody is unique. Comparisons just bring us far from the truth. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Thanks, Cecilia. Well said. We are certainly all unique with our individual personalities.

      Like

  49. Raj Kumar Avatar
    Raj Kumar

    Your posts really represent Asian culture .It bridges the communication with other cultures and people.keep writing.

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      Thank you, Raj. Asian culture is always fascinating. Each Asian ethnic group has their own traditions and customs, most of which are constantly evolving and we can learn from that.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Raj Kumar Avatar
        Raj Kumar

        I 2 like to learn different cultures.May be u can let me know more about ur experiences and cultures.

        Liked by 1 person

  50. milaiski Avatar

    I’m the opposite. I am unusually tall and bigger than most Filipinos, so I usually stand out in a sea of usually petite and skinny Filipinos. Yet, surprise we perceive/feel the same things. At the end of the day, who cares, right? What matters is we accept ourselves for who we are. 🙂

    Like

    1. Mabel Kwong Avatar

      I’ve always pictured you short and petite! At least you can see above everyone’s heads, and perhaps see better at concerts. You are right. If we’re comfortable with ourselves and our bodies, there’s no stopping what we can do 🙂

      Like

Leave a reply to phb2003 Cancel reply